The problem
Every return, however simple, waited in the same Member Services line.
Three versions, one lesson
I tested in a real club before scaling. 40 members observed. The biggest fix wasn't on the screen.
The bigger picture · one Returns program, two channels
Kiosk and curbside weren't separate ideas. Both tested the same question: will members handle a return their own way, if we meet them where they already are? Each started as a scrappy pilot on Express Returns, the app associates already used, so we could learn fast before building anything new.
32%of eligible returns, double the 15% target
Proved members are happy to finish a simple return on their own, without waiting in line for an associate.
10%adoption in 5 weeks, across 3 clubs
Proved members will return without leaving the car, when an associate brings the return to them.
Nextwhat both pilots point to
Pick items, answer questions and see the refund in the app, then just drop off at the kiosk or the curb.
Every return, however simple, waited in the same Member Services line.
I tested in a real club before scaling. 40 members observed. The biggest fix wasn't on the screen.



Self-service only works if the space explains itself. I storyboarded the walk from entrance to drop-off.






Five steps, screen to drop-off.
Exclusions up front, so members know before they begin.

Each answer collapses. “This won't impact your refund.”

Exact amount and card, before anything prints.

“Attach to item” for members. Item, reason and condition for associates.


Every labeled item goes into one return slot. Associates sort behind the counter.
Return complete.

Use the arrows or scroll sideways · tap any screen to enlarge
Prototype screens recreate the real experience with dummy data, so some names, prices and item numbers are placeholders.













No scanner, separate bins and the old label were deliberate. Real members showed what to fix.
What didn't work: in the pilot, members sorted every item themselves into Bin A, Bin B or the trash. They stopped, reread the signs, and items still landed in the wrong place. Clearer signs wouldn't help, because the choice itself was the problem.
What worked: the revised station has a single return slot. Members drop every labeled item into one opening, and associates sort behind the counter using the label. The last step became one simple action.
Move the decisions out of the club, so the kiosk visit shrinks to three quick steps.
In-club associate interviews, plus a survey of people who'd made a return in the last 12 months.
Associates relied on memory, not the written policy.
→ The system decides eligibility, not the member.Gift returns, missing history and $100+ items needed judgment.
→ Automate the predictable. Route the rest.Time limits, fees and exceptions were the top questions.
→ Show what can't be returned before they start.A quick return waited behind complex membership help.
→ Don't fix the queue. Give simple returns a way around it.Next case study“Automate the predictable. Save people for the moments that need them.”
Some of this work is confidential, so I share the details one-on-one. Happy to walk you through it.