Self-service · 2025–2026

Reimagining returns as a fast, intuitive self-service experience.

★Part of the Walmart MAD Award–winning Returns experience
Video prototype · a full return, start to finish
Company
Sam's Club (Walmart)
Domain
Retail · Returns
Role
Lead Product Designer · owned design end to end
Team
PM, engineering, research, store ops

The bigger picture · one Returns program, two channels

Two experiments, one direction.

Kiosk and curbside weren't separate ideas. Both tested the same question: will members handle a return their own way, if we meet them where they already are? Each started as a scrappy pilot on Express Returns, the app associates already used, so we could learn fast before building anything new.

  1. Step 1 · Inside the club

    Kiosk: self-service

    32%of eligible returns, double the 15% target

    Proved members are happy to finish a simple return on their own, without waiting in line for an associate.

  2. Step 2 · At the curb

    Curbside: assisted

    10%adoption in 5 weeks, across 3 clubs

    Proved members will return without leaving the car, when an associate brings the return to them.

  3. Step 3 · The end goal

    Start at home

    Nextwhat both pilots point to

    Pick items, answer questions and see the refund in the app, then just drop off at the kiosk or the curb.

01

The problem

Every return, however simple, waited in the same Member Services line.

32% ↑ trendingadoption across eligible returns, more than double our 15% target
98%of kiosk returns completed in under 1 minute
02

Three versions, one lesson

I tested in a real club before scaling. 40 members observed. The biggest fix wasn't on the screen.

Early Express Returns prototype built from white panels, with cubbies, drop doors A and B, a tablet and a printer
V1 · PrototypeBuilt in weeks to test the idea
Club pilot at Member Services: a kiosk counter with tablet and label printer beside bins A and B and a trash can
V2 · Club pilotMembers hesitated at Bin A, Bin B or trash
Revised Self-Serve Returns station in plywood with a single return opening, a tablet, label printer, handheld scanner and return bags
V3 · RevisedOne opening, a handheld scanner, return bags
17+ of 40 members struggled to scan their receipt in the pilot.
What we saw → what I changed
  • Glare and placement made receipts fail; members looked for a handheld scannerAdded a handheld scanner
  • Members expected to start with their membership cardAdded membership card scanning
  • Unsure the kiosk recognized themGreeted by name, with a clear next step
  • Kiosk looked frozen while loadingProgress and status messages
  • Long item listsScanned item first, grouped by eligibility
  • Condition felt riskyOne question at a time, with reassurance
  • Bin A, Bin B or trash for every itemOne return opening; associates sort behind the scenes
03

Designing the space

Self-service only works if the space explains itself. I storyboarded the walk from entrance to drop-off.

Storyboard 01, Enter: Members spot Member Services from the entrance.
01 EnterMembers spot Member Services from the entrance.
Storyboard 02, Approach: “We get it, life's busy” signage explains the station.
02 Approach“We get it, life's busy” signage explains the station.
Storyboard 03, Line start: Wayfinding splits self-serve from the desk line.
03 Line startWayfinding splits self-serve from the desk line.
Storyboard 04, Return start: Kiosk, how-to card and label printer, side by side.
04 Return startKiosk, how-to card and label printer, side by side.
Storyboard 05, Bin drop: Pilot layout: bins A and B, plus trash.
05 Bin dropBins A and B, with a separate trash can.
Storyboard 06, Return end: Return complete, with a quick rating.
06 Return endReturn complete, with a quick rating.
04

The final flow

Five steps, screen to drop-off.

  1. 01

    Start with what can't be returned

    Exclusions up front, so members know before they begin.

    Kiosk welcome screen: Start your return, with options to scan a receipt or a membership card, and icons for items to take to the Member Services desk
  2. 02

    One question at a time

    Each answer collapses. “This won't impact your refund.”

    Item details screen: the answered reason collapses to No longer needed, followed by item condition with a note that it will not affect the refund
  3. 03

    Confirm the refund

    Exact amount and card, before anything prints.

    Refund summary screen with subtotal, tax and refund total, the card the refund goes back to, the receipt email, and a Print return label button
  4. 04

    One label, two readers

    “Attach to item” for members. Item, reason and condition for associates.

    Kiosk status screen: Labels are printing, shown over the refund summary
    The kiosk says what's happening while it prints
    Printed test label reading Attach to item, this isn't a receipt, with item, masked membership number, condition and reason, item number, barcode, time stamp and a K for kiosk
    A printed test label
  5. 05

    Drop & go

    Every labeled item goes into one return slot. Associates sort behind the counter.

    Return complete.

    Print, attach, drop
    Return complete screen: Thanks, Sam. A refund of $11.20 is on its way. Receipt emailed, a five-star rating prompt, and Have another return?
    Return complete

Every screen, in order

Use the arrows or scroll sideways · tap any screen to enlarge

Prototype screens recreate the real experience with dummy data, so some names, prices and item numbers are placeholders.

  1. Screen 1: Start your return
    01Start your return
  2. Screen 2: Scan with the hand scanner
    02Scan with the hand scanner
  3. Screen 3: Pick eligible items
    03Pick eligible items
  4. Screen 4: Item selected, Continue on
    04Item selected, Continue on
  5. Screen 5: How many, and why
    05How many, and why
  6. Screen 6: One question at a time
    06One question at a time
  7. Screen 7: All answered, Submit on
    07All answered, Submit on
  8. Screen 8: Refund summary
    08Refund summary
  9. Screen 9: Never looks frozen
    09Never looks frozen
  10. Screen 10: Labels printing
    10Labels printing
  11. Screen 11: The return label
    11The return label
  12. Screen 12: Drop-off steps
    12Label, bag, drop
  13. Screen 13: Return complete
    13Return complete
05

What I learned

  1. Scrappy first, then right

    No scanner, separate bins and the old label were deliberate. Real members showed what to fix.

  2. Remove the decision, don't explain it

    What didn't work: in the pilot, members sorted every item themselves into Bin A, Bin B or the trash. They stopped, reread the signs, and items still landed in the wrong place. Clearer signs wouldn't help, because the choice itself was the problem.

    What worked: the revised station has a single return slot. Members drop every labeled item into one opening, and associates sort behind the counter using the label. The last step became one simple action.

What I'd design next: start the return at home, drop it off at the club.

Move the decisions out of the club, so the kiosk visit shrinks to three quick steps.

Today, all at the kiosk
  1. Scan
  2. Select
  3. Answer
  4. Refund
  5. Label
  6. Drop
Next
At home, in the app
  1. Select
  2. Answer
  3. Refund
At the club
  1. Scan code
  2. Label
  3. Drop
Behind the designResearch, guardrails & accessibility

Research

In-club associate interviews, plus a survey of people who'd made a return in the last 12 months.

  • 500survey respondents
  • 5associates interviewed
  • 2clubs

Policy was ambiguous

Associates relied on memory, not the written policy.

→ The system decides eligibility, not the member.

Exceptions need people

Gift returns, missing history and $100+ items needed judgment.

→ Automate the predictable. Route the rest.

Members wanted clarity first

Time limits, fees and exceptions were the top questions.

→ Show what can't be returned before they start.

One line, different needs

A quick return waited behind complex membership help.

→ Don't fix the queue. Give simple returns a way around it.
Predictable return→ Kiosk
  • Purchase identified
  • Eligibility confirmed
  • No judgment required
Complex return→ Associate
  • Gift or missing purchase
  • Prohibited item
  • Policy exception

The physical system

Placement
Can members find it?
Signage
Is its purpose clear from a distance?
Bins
What size and number fit real volume?
Labels
Can members match item to destination?
Packaging
What if an item needs containing?
Spoiled items
Where do they go instead?
Disposal
How do we keep trash out of returns?

Guardrails & accessibility

  • Eyes on the floor. Associates and UX researchers observed the pilot and talked with members and associates.
  • Self-service mode, not a separate device. A timeout screen, plus an associate-only home button to switch the iPad back to desk returns at Member Services.
  • Accessibility review. The kiosk was tested with Walmart's accessibility team, and we made changes from their guidance.

“Automate the predictable. Save people for the moments that need them.”

Next case study

Who says returns can only happen at a kiosk?

Curbside Returns: my idea, built with what we already had.

Curbside Returns

Questions, or want the full walkthrough?

Some of this work is confidential, so I share the details one-on-one. Happy to walk you through it.

Quick read · about a minute

Kiosk Returns, in a minute.

Lead Product Designer · Sam's Club (Walmart) · 2025–2026

ProblemEvery return, even a simple one, waited in the same Member Services line for an associate.

SolutionA self-service kiosk and drop-off station where members finish eligible returns on their own.

Jump to a chapter

  1. 01The problem
  2. 02Three versions
  3. 03The space
  4. 04Final flow
  5. 05What I learned