Service design · 2025 · 6 months

What if a return never required stepping inside the club?

★Car to completion in under 5 minutes · MAD Award–winning Returns
Company
Sam's Club (Walmart)
Domain
Retail · Returns
Role
Lead Designer · originated the concept, owned design end to end
Team
Research, product, engineering, ops

The bigger picture · one Returns program, two channels

Two experiments, one direction.

Kiosk and curbside weren't separate ideas. Both tested the same question: will members handle a return their own way, if we meet them where they already are? Each started as a scrappy pilot on Express Returns, the app associates already used, so we could learn fast before building anything new.

  1. Step 1 · Inside the club

    Kiosk: self-service

    32%of eligible returns, double the 15% target

    Proved members are happy to finish a simple return on their own, without waiting in line for an associate.

  2. Step 2 · At the curb

    Curbside: assisted

    10%adoption in 5 weeks, across 3 clubs

    Proved members will return without leaving the car, when an associate brings the return to them.

  3. Step 3 · The end goal

    Start at home

    Nextwhat both pilots point to

    Pick items, answer questions and see the refund in the app, then just drop off at the kiosk or the curb.

01

The problem

A return still meant parking, walking in and waiting at Member Services. Members already used curbside to get products into their car. Curbside returns started as my idea: could the same curbside take products back?

3clubs piloted
10%adoption in 5 weeks
25%lift in member satisfaction
<5 mincar to completion
02

Scrappy first, then built

Prove the behavior before building the technology.

Phase 1 · 3 weeks · Plano, TX

Pilot with what already existed

Associates used the Express Returns iPad app from Member Services. One email told pickup members returns had moved to the curb.

Phase 2 · Adoption grew

Put returns on the device in their hand

I adapted Express Returns into an Android app for the handheld associates already carry for pickup orders.

Tradeoff: Phase 1's iPad app wasn't built for one hand outdoors. We accepted that to prove demand first.

Phase 1 storyboard: curbside returns highlighted in the pickup confirmation email, member arrives, tells the associate they have a return, return processed in the Express Returns app, refund confirmed
Phase 1 storyboard: no new tools or training.
03

Design iterations

What changed once associates used it at the curb.

01

Item details: sheets → one step at a time

Bottom sheets felt complicated in bright sun. After testing with associates, each question became its own step, and Add item only turns on when the item is complete.

Before
Earlier item details with condition, quantity and reason fields
All fields on one screen
Earlier bottom sheet listing return reasons
Reason in a bottom sheet
After
Item details showing item condition options
Condition first
Item details with quantity stepper and reason, Add item enabled
Then quantity and reason
02

Start: receipt → membership

Lead with the membership card. One scan pulls up the member's purchases. Receipt and order search stay one tap away.

Before
Earlier start screen with Scan receipt and Type receipt number
Receipt first
After
Start screen with Scan receipt, Scan membership code and Search by order number
Membership first
Camera view scanning a membership card barcode
Scan the card
03

Refund: choose → choose and confirm

A refund can't be undone at the curb. The method shows speed upfront, then one explicit confirm before it goes through.

Before
Earlier payment summary with card or eGift card
Choose a method
After
Refund summary: card in 3 to 5 days or eGift card ready now
Speed upfront
Confirm payment details dialog: this will complete the return and can't be reversed
Explicit confirm
04

The final flow

From trunk to refund, without leaving the car.

  1. Park
  2. Check in
  3. Verify
  4. Hand off
  5. Refund
  6. Go
  1. 01

    Arrive

    MemberParks in a Returns spot and checks in.

    AssociateHeads out with the pickup handheld.

    Pilot: QR, text or call. Future: app check-in.

  2. 02

    Identify

    MemberShows their membership card.

    AssociateScans it to pull up purchases.

  3. 03

    Verify

    MemberHands over the item.

    AssociateScans and matches it to the purchase.

    Future: know what's coming before reaching the car.

  4. 04

    Refund

    MemberPicks where the money goes.

    AssociateConfirms the refund at the car.

  5. 05

    Done

    MemberDrives away. Receipt by email.

The handheld flow, end to end

Use the arrows or scroll sideways · tap any screen to enlarge

Prototype screens recreate the real experience with dummy data, so some names, prices and item numbers are placeholders.

Find the member

  1. Start: scan the membership
    01Start: scan the membership
  2. Scan the card
    02Scan the card
  3. Or type the number
    03Or type the number

Find the item

  1. Return started for the member
    04Return started for the member
  2. Scan the item
    05Scan the item
  3. Or search by name or UPC
    06Or search by name or UPC
  4. Purchase history with orders listed by date; one order greyed out and flagged Return to Member Services desk
    07Pick the purchase. Ineligible ones are flagged.
  5. Match the item on the receipt
    08Match the item on the receipt

Item details

  1. Condition
    09Condition
  2. Quantity and reason, then Add item
    10Quantity and reason, then Add item
  3. Review the return bin
    11Review the return bin

Refund

  1. Choose where the refund goes
    12Choose where the refund goes
  2. Confirm payment details dialog: issue refund to VISA 1234, this will complete the return and can't be reversed, Go back or Yes
    13Confirm. It can't be reversed.

When things go wrong

  1. Membership not found: try again
    14Membership not found: try again
  2. Item not found: try again
    15Item not found: try again
  3. System problem: send to Member Services
    16System problem: send to Member Services
  4. Not eligible for curbside
    17Not eligible for curbside
05

What I learned

  1. Pilot the behavior before building the technology

    A low-tech pilot proved demand and showed what was worth building.

  2. Speed without predictability still feels slow

    Clear arrival steps mattered as much as a fast refund.

Behind the designResearch, service design & validation

The insight

The frustration wasn't only wait time, it was control. Members wanted chores that fit around their day.

Product principleDon't make members come to the return. Bring the return to them.

Reuse before rebuilding

Reused

  • Curbside spots & associates
  • Express Returns
  • Purchase history

Designed new

  • Entry points & signage
  • Associate workflow
  • The handoff at the car

Designed for the future too: app check-in, automatic eligibility, arrival detection and wait-time visibility.

Designing the service

Digital
QR codes, check-in, the app, confirmation
Physical
Dedicated parking, signage, wayfinding
Operational
Associate availability, item collection
Technical
Network, purchase lookup, devices
Communication
Arrival steps, wait expectations, refund confirmation
Journey mapping surfaced three critical moments
  • Discovering curbside returns exist
  • Knowing what to do on arrival
  • Knowing what's happening while the refund processes
Flowchart following a member through curbside returns at club 6255: member parks in a dedicated return spot with signage and a QR code, associate walks to the spot with a device, processes the steps, refund processing, then confirmation, text, email, survey and offer
The member path and the associate path, mapped at club #6255.

App principles

Same device as pickup
Nothing new to carry to the car
Scan first, type as backup
Search is always one tap away
One question at a time
Bottom sheets felt complicated in bright sun. Testing moved us to one step at a time.
Return bin
Multi-item returns stay easy to review
Refund speed, upfront
Card in 3–5 days or eGift now, then confirm
Errors say what's next
Try again, or send to Member Services

Validated in the field

  • 20curbside associates interviewed
  • 3regions: Texas, New Jersey, Concord CA
  • A11yreviewed with the accessibility team

Right after deploying, we talked to associates and surveyed them on training time, ease of use and time to complete a return.

A five-minute return only feels fast when every minute feels predictable.

Next case study

Back to where AI shipped first.

Gen AI Summaries: the first Gen AI feature in the contact center.

Gen AI Summaries

Questions, or want the full walkthrough?

Some of this work is confidential, so I share the details one-on-one. Happy to walk you through it.

Quick read · about a minute

Curbside Returns, in a minute.

Lead Designer · originated the concept · Sam's Club (Walmart) · 2025

ProblemReturning meant parking, walking in and waiting at Member Services.

SolutionReturns from the car: associates process them at the curb on the handheld they already carry.

Jump to a chapter

  1. 01The problem
  2. 02Scrappy first
  3. 03Iterations
  4. 04Final flow
  5. 05What I learned